Key Points Covered in this Podcast:
- Separate leaders from the companies they run. You may admire a business leader, but the company they lead may not be a good investment; the two should be evaluated independently.
- There is no extra compensation for taking on diversifiable risk, so investors should diversify broadly across and within all major global asset classes rather than concentrating in NVIDIA, AI stocks, or U.S. large-cap equities.
- Understand the real catalyst. About three-quarters of NVIDIA’s 30% sell-off occurred before the scandal broke, driven largely by a broader AI sector sell-off tied to the U.S. midterm elections and anticipated AI regulation — not just the leadership change.
- The three goals of bond investing exist in tension with one another — income, diversification, and capital preservation each pull in different directions, so investors should work closely with their adviser to understand why they own bonds and which vehicles best suit their needs.
- Bond vehicles each have distinct pros and cons — ETFs offer liquidity and intraday trading, individual bonds and municipal bonds are less liquid but serve specific purposes
Transcript
Hello, everybody. Thank you for joining us this morning. Today is Friday, November 13, and the topic of today’s Market Perspective podcast is to provide a little bit of commentary and framing on the recent headlines with respect to NVIDIA. If you’ve been paying attention, you have seen that NVIDIA has replaced its CEO, Jensen Huang, the founder of NVIDIA, who ran the company for thirty three years.
He resigned yesterday morning. That’s when the story broke. And so what I wanted to do today was provide a little bit of context and a little bit of history around what perhaps led up to this. And then also, most importantly, what are the key lessons that we as investors could perhaps take away from this big this big change.
I mean, NVIDIA today is one of the…
In fact, actually, the most highly valuable company in the S and P five hundred index and is really the backbone of the AI sector for all intents and purposes. So before I get started, I just wanted to acknowledge that we know that for many of our clients that NVIDIA has been and continues to be a very important part of either your professional life or certainly your financial life and that these leadership changes, certainly a leadership change of this magnitude, that this can cause a significant number of questions all at once. And so, again, the purpose of today is to try to provide a little bit of context some guidance for how we could and should perhaps think about what is happening with NVIDIA.
So first and foremost, let… Let’s just do a a quick a quick recap.
Despite yesterday’s headlines, when we when we zoom out just a little bit and look at NVIDIA stock performance over the past quarter, the stock actually closed at a record high on October 6. And through yesterday’s close, the stock is down about 30%, just a little bit over 30%. Yesterday, the stock fell a little bit over 4% on the news that Jensen Huang had resigned from NVIDIA in the wake of a Chinese… An alleged Chinese spying scandal, but also alleged extramarital affairs with the alleged Chinese spy. Her name is Alice Huang.
No relation to Jensen, but she is the chief executive at a company called Mega Speed, which is a large NVIDIA customer that has been suspected of diverting high powered NVIDIA chips to to China in violation of U.S. law.
So that’s a little bit just on the stock performance here since October since October 6. To give you a little bit more context, during that time, the S and P 500 index fell about 2.8%. So here we are, a very diversified, broad U.S.
Large cap index down only about 2.8%, yet NVIDIA down about 30% in that in that time. To be fair, there’s been a broader sell off in the technology sector since October since October 6. So we’ll we’ll touch on that here in a few moments.
So given this 30% sell off in NVIDIA since October since October 6, there’s this question around, gee, you know, what really fueled this sell off? Was it was it exclusively these alleged extramarital affairs? Was it something different? Was it related to revenues?
And if if we just look at the timeline, about three quarters of that sell off occurred prior to late October. It was October 29 when a story first broke that U. S. Intelligence was investigating, NVIDIA, specifically an executive at a firm called Mega Speed, and there was concern that that executive had a very close, perhaps romantic relationship with Jensen.
And so so let…
Let’s look at the pre late October, the pre October 29 performance, about three quarters of that. And then we can take a look at, you know, what what really perhaps precipitated the sell off here more recently.
And and I think the first thing we like to look at is things like fundamentals, revenue, and earnings, and earnings growth, and all of those things. And I think when we look at NVIDIA’s performance, I mean, by any objective measure, I mean, the stock has done amazingly well. Revenue growth has been strong. Earnings growth has been strong.
Its valuation, is at about 23 times next year’s earnings. That’s certainly high, but it’s not abnormally high. It’s very much in the same neighborhood as many other AI and AI adjacent type companies. So I don’t think we can make a really strong argument that the sell off in NVIDIA beginning in the wake of October 6, after October 6, than any of that really had anything to do with with fundamentals.
In fact, even one analyst…
One analysis that I saw actually argued that NVIDIA is really trading at about 11 times next year’s earnings when you look at how rapidly the firm’s earnings continue to grow. So definitely, you know, from a fundamentals perspective, I don’t see any evidence here that that’s what has fueled this sell off. I know some investors, some clients have asked me, you know, gee, aren’t aren’t these AI companies just wildly overpriced? Is, you know, is there a bubble in the AI trade?
And, again, I think when we look at the valuations, we compare those valuations to the S and P five hundred index, which trades at about 18 times earnings.
I think, you know, certainly there’s a premium there, but I don’t think it’s an abnormally high premium, at least by historical standards.
So again, not earnings, not a valuation problem that I’m seeing at the moment. And in fact, there was actually a broader sell off in AI and AI adjacent companies really leading up to the U.S. midterm elections. And I actually think that that is probably more so the catalyst for the sell off in AI companies since early October. I think the market was pricing in the likelihood, the probability of a blue sweep, of a democratic sweep, certainly of the house, increasingly of the senate leading up to the midterms.
And we know now that it certainly was a a blue wave or a blue tsunami depending on how you wanna characterize it. But I think the bigger news is the evidence that democratic governorships were…
That a number of the governorships were going to go to democrats. Since more of the AI infrastructure build out, AI data center build out, a lot of that is all happening naturally at the state levels and there’s certainly a significant pushback from citizens across The United States around the building of data centers in communities and things like that. So I think that, you know, if we’re looking for one catalyst to just kind of point our finger at and say, maybe that is why we saw this broader sell off, I think that makes some sense. You know, regulatory changes appear to be coming for the AI sector.
Interestingly, NVIDIA’s worst performance was November 5, two days after the midterm elections when it became clear that a significant number of governorships across The United States had flipped and were going to Democrats. Many of these governors, governor elects, were very vocal that new regulations are certainly coming for AI companies and AI adjacent type companies. And so I think that regulatory, headwind is what led largely to that sell off throughout October and into early November. With respect to NVIDIA, I think it is also clear that once these stories began to break, that that certainly piled on the stock.
And so let me just summarize for our listeners really what happened here. The news started to break, like I said, in late October, that U.S. intelligence believed that an executive at a major NVIDIA customer, that firm is Mega Speed, and her name is Alice Huang, that that she had a relationship with Jensen Huang. Again, no relation between them. And that her company Mega Speed had been diverting chips, high powered NVIDIA chips to Chinese companies.
And that would certainly be in violation of U.S. law. Now the the framing of that relationship as an extramarital affair, actually did not come until several days later. Sometime around November 6 is when the media began to frame that relationship, as as being romantic in in nature. And so, on November 8, the board, NVIDIA’s board, had announced that they were opening an investigation into the allegations that Jensen Huang had a relationship, a romantic relationship with Alice Huang from Mega Speed and investigating whether or not there had been any compromise of U.S. National security. The board maintained that there was no compromise of U.S. National security.
Certainly the Department of Justice, the FBI, U. S. Intelligence agencies, I don’t think have opined on that since. I have not seen anything.
I’ve been looking and have not seen any evidence that they have a different view at the moment. But on November 11, the New York Times reported a second affair with an NVIDIA executive who reportedly, reported directly into Jensen. And in most companies, that would be a a major a major problem. And so it was late late November 11 that evening, I remember seeing some headlines that the board was meeting.
And I even saw a couple of headlines get out ahead of themselves claiming that the board had already fired Jensen. That was not the case. Yesterday morning, when we all got up and we were checking the headlines, it was clear that the board had not made a decision just yet. But it was sometime yesterday morning, I forget, probably around 08:30, when the news broke that Jensen had indeed resigned from his position as the chief executive officer of NVIDIA.
And so that is a very significant change for one of America’s and indeed one of the world’s most valuable publicly traded companies. There has since since his resignation, there’s been a few other headlines that have broke that have, alleged that about $7,500,000,000 in NVIDIA chips had been diverted to China by way of this firm called Mega Speed. And there were…
There’s also been some allegations that there was perhaps a third extramarital affair. So definitely a fast moving story. So what should investors make of all this? This is a significant amount of new information.
We’ve seen a significant sell off in NVIDIA as we’ve discussed since October 6. So what are the lessons to be learned from all of this? I I think the first lesson, and I already touched on this, is that first and foremost, investors should just take a deep breath and hit the pause button.
There is a lot of fast moving information. Some of the information that came out initially was later shown to be inaccurate. It makes a lot of sense to just put some distance between stimulus and response. You know, in thirty years of being in this business, I’ve never seen a good outcome come from making an investment decision quickly. It makes a lot of sense to just slow things down, catch your breath, let’s get all of the available information, and then from there, we can assess what the best path forward looks like for each of us individually.
Just to give you a little bit more context on that point, yesterday morning, when the news first broke that Jensen Huang had resigned, futures for Nvidia were down about 10 to 12%. However, the stock actually closed yesterday down only about 4.34%. So I’m not here to minimize the volatility that we saw in the stock or to minimize the 4% sell off, but it’s very different from a 10 to 12% sell off in the futures market when that news first broke. So I think you give you give these things some time, let the information work its way into prices, and then from there, you can ultimately assess what makes the most sense for you and your family.
Second, this underscores why as investors, we should resist putting unquestionable faith in any business leader. And we should also separate business leaders from the companies that they run. You you, you know, you you may like a given business leader, but the company they run may not be a very good investment. And so I think I would just separate the two.
This isn’t meant to be an indictment of Jensen Huang. I think he’s an amazing leader. He was a visionary, great company. I mean, NVIDIA was really the backbone and remains the backbone of the AI trade.
At the same time, we should be careful that when you have these founder led firms where the founder has been the CEO for so long that many of these firms often struggle from governance failures. They don’t have good controls or good checks and balances in place to make sure that that leader continues to manage the company in the best interests of shareholders. And I’m not here to make any allegations. I think that’s why we have investigations and, the Department of Justice and so on and so forth. But as investors, we should resist putting this religious like faith in any leader of any firm. There is value in keeping those things separate.
Third, this is really the biggest and most important takeaway from this episode, is that at every available opportunity, we as investors should work hard to find ways to diversify our portfolios. NVIDIA is a great company. AI is a great sector. AI will continue to transform the American and indeed the global economy. That does not mean that we should be overweight Nvidia or overweight AI stocks or even overweight U.S. large cap stocks in our portfolios. There is value in diversifying broadly across and within major global asset classes.
You know, I use this example often. If we go back to the financial crisis, before the financial crisis really took hold, Lehman Brothers had the highest insider ownership among the major Wall Street investment banks. The firm also had more PhDs on staff than any of the other major Wall Street investment banks. And yet that firm spectacularly failed in September 2008 because the firm was taking on a significant amount of sloppy risks.
And in hindsight, many of those employee shareholders did not realize that that firm was taking on those kinds of risks. What am I trying to say? What I’m trying to say is no matter how well you think you know a company, no matter how well you think you know their financials, their business, their sector, even if you are an employee of that organization, there are often things we don’t know inside of those organizations that could harm shareholder value.
And so whether you are an insider, whether you are someone who has acquired a significant stake in a company, it makes a lot of sense to diversify that position as much as humanly possible. Now we wanna be smart about that. If you are an employee insider of an organization, there are legal constraints. We recognize that. We understand that.
There are also tax constraints. Right? Certainly, capital gains could be a very significant barrier to diversifying a concentrated position. So I’m not trying to be Pollyannish about this. I’m not trying to ignore all of those things. Those are very important considerations.
But I think the most important consideration needs to be the risk that comes with being under diversified. There is no expected return. There is no extra compensation that we earn as investors by taking on diversifiable risks in the market. So it makes a lot of sense to diversify your holdings as much as humanly possible. And I want to give you some framing here for a moment.
Nvidia makes up a little bit over 8% of the S and P 500 index. However, if you were to own a well diversified global equity portfolio, so let’s just assume a global equity portfolio. Let’s assume you don’t own any bonds, no private equity, no private credit, nothing like that, no real estate.
Just a global equity portfolio typically has anywhere from three to 4% in Nvidia stock. So that is less than half of the weighting that Nvidia makes up in the S and P 500 index. So a very simple way to diversify your portfolio and effectively go underweight some of these very large mega cap U.S. companies is simply to diversify your portfolio, own a basket of global equities. And then when you actually start feathering in bonds, fixed income, real estate, private equity, private credit, so on and so forth, perhaps some cash, naturally, that three to 4% even gets smaller and smaller and smaller. And so when you’re trying to think through, gee, what would be the exposure in my portfolio? Whether it’s a Mercer managed portfolio or or managed somewhere else, ask yourself, how diversified am I? And if you are exceptionally well diversified, I think the impact on your portfolio will be relatively negligible.
If, on the other hand, you own only the S and P five hundred index or even worse, if you only own a handful of technology stocks, well then certainly these recent headlines are going to have a more detrimental impact on your portfolio. So I think that final lesson, it’s an evergreen lesson that I know that I bring up and I drive home listeners and to our clients on a regular basis is is to broadly diversify at every available opportunity.
So to close out this particular episode of our Market Perspectives podcast, I did did just wanna encourage everyone.
If you’re concerned, if you have questions around what this really means for you and your family, please feel free to reach out to us. That’s what we’re here for. We have a team here that stands ready to support you. We can help you analyze what this really means for you and your family, what the impact is, but also importantly to help you understand what are your options going forward.
What would the tax impact be, perhaps, of liquidating part of a concentrated equity position? So I encourage you, please feel free to reach out to us. That’s what we’re here for. We’re here to serve you. We’re here to help.
If you have any questions, again, please feel free to reach out directly to your advisor. So with that, I wish you all a wonderful weekend. And until next time, goodbye.
This presentation by Mercer Global Advisors Incorporated, also known as Mercer Advisors, was intended for general information purposes only. No portion of the presentation serves as the receipt of or as a substitute for personalized investment advice from Mercer advisors.
For general information purposes only. No portion of the podcast serves as the receipt of, or as a substitute for, personalized investment advice from Mercer Advisors. All expressions of opinion reflect the judgment of the speaker as of the date of recording and are subject to change. Some of the research and ratings provided in this podcast come from third parties that are not affiliated with Mercer Advisors. The information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed or warranted by Mercer Advisors. Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and it should not be assumed that future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy, or any non-investment related planning services, discussion, or content, will be profitable, be suitable for your portfolio or individual situation, or prove successful. This podcast does not imply a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any referenced security or engage in any particular investment strategy. Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or guarantee against loss. Past performance may not be indicative of future results. Historical performance results for investment indexes and/or asset classes, generally do not reflect the deduction of transaction and/or custodial charges or the deduction of an investment-management fee, the incurrence of which would have the effect of decreasing historical performance results. Economic factors, market conditions, and investment strategies will affect the performance of any portfolio and there are no assurances that it will match or outperform any particular benchmark. The podcast may contain forward-looking statements including statements regarding our intent, belief or current expectations with respect to market conditions. Listeners are cautioned not to place undue reliance on these forward-looking statements. While due care has been used in the preparation of forecast information, actual results may vary in a materially positive or negative manner. No portion of the content should be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that they will experience a certain level of results if Mercer Advisors is engaged, or continues to be engaged, to provide investment advisory services. Private investments are subject to substantial risks, including limited liquidity. Therefore, private investments are not suitable for all investors. Options investing involve unique risks, tax consequences and commission charges and are not suitable for all investors.
This presentation may contain forward-looking statements including statements regarding our intent, belief or current expectations with respect to market conditions. Listeners are cautioned not to place undue reliance on these forward-looking statements. While due care has been used in the preparation of forecast information, actual results may vary in a materially positive or negative manner. No portion of the content should be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if Mercer Advisors is engaged, or continues to be engaged, to provide investment advisory services. Hypothetical examples are for illustrative purposes only.